当前位置 :
【GMATCR,needurhelpRaymondBurrplayedtheroleoflawyerPerryMasonontelevision.Burr’sdeathin1993promptedaprominentlawyertosay“Althoughnotalawyer,Mr.Burrstroveforsuchauthenticitythatwefeelasifwelostoneofourown.”】
1人问答
更新时间:2024-04-28 05:40:25
问题描述:

GMATCR,needurhelp

RaymondBurrplayedtheroleoflawyerPerryMasonontelevision.Burr’sdeathin1993promptedaprominentlawyertosay“Althoughnotalawyer,Mr.Burrstroveforsuchauthenticitythatwefeelasifwelostoneofourown.”Thiscommentfromaprestigiousattorneyprovidesappallingevidencethat,inthefaceoftelevision,evensomelegalprofessionalsarelosingtheirabilitytodistinguishfictionfromreality.

Thereasoningintheargumentisflawedbecausetheargument

(A)takestheviewsofonelawyertorepresenttheviewsofalllawyers

(B)criticizesthelawyerratherthanthelawyer’sstatement

(C)presumesthatthelawyerisqualifiedtoevaluatetheperformanceofanactor

(D)focusesonafamousactor’sportrayalofalawyerratherthanontheusualwayinwhichlawyersareportrayedontelevision

(E)ignoresthepartofthelawyer’sremarkthatindicatesanawarenessofthedifferencebetweenrealityandfiction

Yes

butcouldushowwhyEiscorrectfromurreasoning?

房立存回答:
  Thelawyersays:"Althoughnotalawyer,Mr.Burrstroveforsuchauthenticitythatwefeelasifwelostoneofourown.”   Itclearlyshowswhenthelawyerstatestheabovewords,heknowsthatMr.Burrwasonlyanactor.SohisclaimofMr.Burrasoneofthemisonlyawaytopraisetheactor,butnottoaccepthimasacolleague.   Hence,ABCDhavenothingtodowiththeargumentthat"somelegalprofessionalsarelosingtheirabilitytodistinguishfictionfromreality".Inotherwords,ABCDareirrelevant.   Therefore,theonlycorrectanswerisE.   ---------------------------------------------------------------   呃是这样的律师说“Althoughnotalawyer”就指E选项里面说的被忽略掉的part因为这清楚的表明他已经知道Mr.Burr不是演员也就是说他并没有将fiction和reality混淆
最新更新
PC端 | 移动端
掌乐学(zhanglexue.com)汇总了汉语字典,新华字典,成语字典,组词,词语,在线查字典,中文字典,英汉字典,在线字典,康熙字典等等,是学生查询学习资料的好帮手,是老师教学的好助手。
声明:本网站尊重并保护知识产权,根据《信息网络传播权保护条例》,如果我们转载的作品侵犯了您的权利,请在一个月内通知我们,我们会及时删除。
Copyright©2009-2021 掌乐学 zhanglexue.com 版权所有 闽ICP备2020019185号-1